Wingman P5 vs Origin8 Wireless: Which PS4 PC Controller?
By Stone Age Gamer | Published: 2026-10-30
Category: Comparisons
Compare the Brook Wingman P5 converter and Retro-Bit Origin8 wireless controller to find the best PS4 or PC setup for your retro gaming needs.
Quick Answer
If you already own a favorite controller and want to use it across PS4, PS5, and PC, the Brook Wingman P5 is the flexible choice. If you want a dedicated wireless NES-style pad for Switch, PC, and USB devices, the Retro-Bit Origin8 is simpler and cheaper.
What Each Option Does
The Brook Wingman P5 is a converter adapter, not a controller. It lets you connect wired and wireless controllers—like Xbox, Switch Pro, or fight sticks—to PS5, PS4, and PC (X-Input). This means you keep the controller you already love and gain cross-platform compatibility.
The Retro-Bit Origin8 is a wireless controller inspired by the classic NES pad. It works with NES, Nintendo Switch, and USB-enabled devices, and includes 4 shoulder buttons, Home, and Screenshot buttons, plus Turbo switches. It’s a complete controller solution for retro fans.
Key Trade-Offs
The Wingman P5 costs more (about $42.69) but adds versatility for multiple platforms and controller types. The Origin8 costs less (about $17.74) but is limited to its own design and compatible devices.
If you play on PS4 or PS5, the Wingman P5 is essential because the Origin8 doesn’t support those consoles. If you stick to Switch, PC, and NES, the Origin8 is a direct wireless option without needing an adapter.
Which Should You Choose?
- Choose Wingman P5 if you need PS4/PS5 support: The Wingman P5 is the only option here that works on PS4 and PS5. If you play on those consoles and want to use your existing controller, this adapter is the way to go.
- Choose Origin8 if you want a dedicated retro wireless pad: The Origin8 is cheaper and gives you a complete wireless controller for NES, Switch, and USB devices. It’s ideal if you don’t need PS4/PS5 compatibility and prefer a simple setup.
- Consider your controller collection: If you already own multiple controllers (Xbox, Switch Pro, fight sticks), the Wingman P5 multiplies their usefulness. If you’re starting fresh and want a retro feel, the Origin8 is a low-cost entry point. Before buying, list the consoles you actually play on to avoid overpaying for features you won’t use.
Product Facts
- Wingman P5 for PS4 PS5 & PC - Brook: The Brook Wingman P5 adapter allows you to use your favorite wired and wireless controllers—including Xbox, Switch Pro, and fight sticks—across PS5, PS4, and PC (X-Input). This means you can keep using the controller you already prefer instead of buying a new one for each platform.
Wingman P5 for PS4 PS5 & PC - Brook - Origin8 2.4 GHz Wireless Controller - Retro-Bit: The Retro-Bit Origin8 is compatible with NES, Nintendo Switch, and USB-enabled devices, and includes 4 shoulder buttons, Home, Screenshot buttons, and Turbo switches. It gives you a wireless NES-style controller that works on modern devices without needing an adapter.
Origin8 2.4 GHz Wireless Controller - Retro-Bit
Perfect Fit
Best for
- PS4/PS5 players who want to use their existing controllers
- PC gamers who want a converter for multiple controller types
Not for
- Retro purists who want a dedicated NES-style wireless pad
- Budget buyers who only need Switch or USB compatibility
